Buy now, pay later is splitting American shoppers almost exactly in half. A survey by the Electronic Transactions Association and TSG found 37% of US consumers view their recent BNPL purchases favourably and 36% unfavourably, while other research shows many plan to use instalments to stretch holiday budgets. The more striking finding is how far BNPL trails everyday payment methods: 81% regularly use tap-to-pay, 61% digital wallets and 60% peer-to-peer apps, against 21% for BNPL. For merchants heading into the holidays, BNPL is worth offering, but convenience is what actually changes behaviour.
Go deeper: how one fee-related case is reshaping payment practices: The $5,318.87 Cancellation Fee.
Who likes it
Millennials are the most positive, at 47% favourable, against 39% of Gen Z, 38% of Gen X and 24% of Baby Boomers, Payments Dive reports. Middle-income consumers (40%) like it slightly more than low- and high-income groups (35% each). Over the past year, 53% tried tap-to-pay, 31% digital wallets and 28% peer-to-peer apps, while only 9% tried BNPL for the first time. “Convenience and familiarity are converting trial into repeat behavior more effectively than novelty alone,” the report says.
Holiday intent is higher. A PayPal survey of 2,005 adults found about six in 10 consumers leaning toward BNPL to extend holiday budgets, and Afterpay said 96% of its customers who used instalments over last year’s Black Friday and Cyber Monday repaid early or on time.
The read
BNPL has settled into a seasonal and situational role: useful for larger holiday purchases, divisive as a habit. The bigger lever for conversion is how quickly customers can pay with the method they already use, whether that’s a tap, a wallet or an app. Merchants should make sure those are available everywhere, show instalment options clearly for higher-value baskets, and present total costs honestly, since that is where regulators and unhappy customers focus.
Written for Red Robot with AI assistance and human editing. Based on reporting by Payments Dive.