The $5,318.87 Cancellation Fee: FTC Sues Toast as Hidden Fees and Hard-to-Cancel Plans Become a Legal Risk

The $5,318.87 Cancellation Fee: FTC Sues Toast as Hidden Fees and Hard-to-Cancel Plans Become a Legal Risk

A $5,318.87 cancellation fee is now a federal case. The FTC and eight states have sued Toast, the restaurant point-of-sale and payments company, alleging hidden fees, add-ons customers didn’t agree to, a $0.99 charge on diners’ online orders that went to Toast, and a cancellation process that is “nonintuitive, time-consuming, far from simple”. Toast denies it and says the subscription law cited doesn’t apply to negotiated business contracts. The same week, Oracle said it will bill per AI task on top of per-seat subscriptions, GM agreed to pay $220 million for selling drivers’ data, and retailers faced public anxiety over dynamic pricing. The thesis is that how you charge, and how easily customers can stop paying, has become a legal and reputational risk in its own right. The safest billing model is one you could explain line by line to a regulator.

Deepen your knowledge: Building Agentic Commerce, Part 1: Why the Agent Era Needs a Callable Backend — our five-part series on what a store needs before AI agents can buy from it.

Go deeper: regulators are already probing personalised pricing, in FTC Orders Delta, Uber, Walmart and Six Others to Explain How They Set Prices, and subscriptions are being re-engineered, in The Subscription War Gets Engineered.

The Toast complaint

The 71-page complaint, filed in federal court in Northern California with 21 counts under the FTC Act, the Restore Online Shoppers’ Confidence Act (ROSCA) and state law, describes several practices, TNW and Payments Dive report:

  • Auto-renewing subscriptions averaging about $900 a month, with add-ons customers say they were charged for without consent.
  • Undisclosed early-termination fees of $150 for each remaining month. One customer was charged $5,318.87 after four years and refused a refund.
  • Hardware conditions: customers must start processing payments within 120 days or return the hardware or pay full retail price, and restaurants that close temporarily still pay $85 a month for processing.
  • A $0.99 fee on diners’ online orders above $10 from September 2021 to July 2023, allegedly without proper disclosure or consent, kept by Toast rather than the restaurant.
  • A cancellation process requiring 30 days’ written notice of “intent not to renew”, which the FTC says was not clearly disclosed. Some customers say they got no reply and kept being charged, or were routed to retention pitches.
  • Loan acceleration: customers with Toast Capital loans who cancel or switch providers are treated as in default and asked to repay the full balance at once.
  • “24/7/365 support” that the FTC says customers struggle to reach.

“Toast failed to honor a number of its promises and instead imposed hidden fees, unauthorized charges and subscription traps,” said the FTC’s Christopher Mufarrige. Toast says it “strongly” disagrees, will “vigorously defend” itself, and argues that “no court has held that ROSCA applies to negotiated business-to-business agreements”. No court has ruled. Toast had $6.15 billion of revenue in 2025, about 82% from payments and loans.

New ways to charge, new ways to get it wrong

The Toast case is about old-fashioned billing practices. Meanwhile, pricing models are becoming more complex. Oracle told investors it will “layer usage-based revenue on top of its subscription model”: “The more work that gets done by AI in our system, the more revenue we will see because they’re consuming AI units,” The Register reports. That is a fair model, but usage-based charges are exactly where surprise bills, unclear units and disputes appear. On the consumer side, Walmart has repeatedly had to deny personalising prices amid worry about digital shelf labels, and states are debating rules on data-driven pricing, Retail Dive reports.

Data is part of the price

GM’s $220 million settlement with 36 states shows the other hidden cost. The states alleged GM sold drivers’ location and driving-behaviour data to brokers that sold it to insurers, raising some premiums. “People bought a car, not a tracking device,” said Oregon’s attorney general, The Verge reports. GM must now obtain express consent and submit to independent assessment, TechCrunch reports. When a customer pays with their data as well as their money, that payment has to be disclosed and consented to as well.

What honest billing looks like

  • Every charge is visible before it is incurred. No fee should appear for the first time on an invoice: setup, add-ons, platform fees and termination fees all belong in the offer.
  • Cancelling is as easy as subscribing. Self-service cancellation with immediate confirmation, no written-notice tricks, no forced retention calls.
  • Usage-based charges have clear units and limits. Customers should be able to see consumption, set caps and get alerts before overages.
  • Every line on an invoice can be explained: which plan, rule or usage produced it.
  • Data use is consented, not assumed. If customer data creates revenue, say so and ask.

Billing built to be explained: VBWD

VBWD, the self-hosted subscription and commerce platform we build, is designed around those principles. The invoice is the system of record. Every charge, whether subscription, add-on, token usage or discount, is a line item with server-side pricing and tax, so any bill can be traced to the rule that produced it. The subscription lifecycle covers trials, renewals, plan changes and cancellations as standard operations rather than support tickets. Usage can be sold as prepaid token bundles, so customers buy capacity upfront instead of discovering overages later (per-feature licensing). Because it is self-hosted, the customer data stays in your own database under your own consent rules. If your billing would struggle to pass a Toast-style review, VBWD offers a free migration assessment.

The read

Hidden fees and hard cancellations have long been treated as revenue optimisation. Regulators now treat them as deception, and the FTC is testing whether consumer subscription rules reach business contracts too. As billing models add usage meters and AI units, the opportunities for surprise charges multiply. The businesses that make every charge visible, every cancellation simple and every invoice line explainable will be the ones that never have to defend a $5,318.87 fee in court.

Written for Red Robot with AI assistance and human editing. VBWD is our own product. Not legal advice. Based on reporting by TNW, Payments Dive, The Register, TechCrunch, The Verge and Retail Dive.

Happy
Happy
0%
Sad
Sad
0%
Excited
Excited
0%
Angry
Angry
0%
Surprise
Surprise
0%
Sleepy
Sleepy
0%
The Open Web Is Closing: Reddit Goes Login-Only as AI Search Stops Sending Traffic

The Open Web Is Closing: Reddit Goes Login-Only as AI Search Stops Sending Traffic

Canada Buys Into ‘Sovereign’ AI as Cohere Raises Up to $5 Billion

Canada Buys Into ‘Sovereign’ AI as Cohere Raises Up to $5 Billion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

twenty − 13 =